It was in Chicago that Earl established himself as one of the best defensemen of his era. He was named to the 1st or 2nd All-Star Team each year between 1935 and 1944, a feat surpassed only by Gordie Howe, Maurice Richard, Bobby Hull and Doug Harvey. Earl was generally regarded as second only to Eddie Shore in terms of skill and rugged play. Although his career was full of great accomplishments, it was compromised by one of the worst accidents in hockey history. On January 28, 1937, in a game against the Montreal Canadiens, Seibert and Howie Morenz chased after a puck behind the Chicago net. Seibert tied up his man on the play, but Morenz fell awkwardly into the boards, breaking his leg. Just six weeks later, Morenz died in hospital, having never recovered emotionally from the devastation of the career-ending injury. Seibert himself never really got over the trauma; whenever he was asked if he'd ever played against Morenz, he'd reply bitterly, "Yeah. I killed him." In 1963 he was elected to the Hockey Hall of Fame and, along with his father, who was elected in 1961, became the first father-son combination ever elected as players.
These following jerseys come from the Earl Seibert estate.
Research assistance thanks goes out to the following: Marc Juteau of Classic Auctions, Stuart Oxenhorn, the Hockey Hall of Fame and SIHR.
First
All-Star
Team
Defense
(1935,
1942,
1943,
1944)
Second
All-Star
Team
Defense
(1936,
1937,
1938,
1939,
1940,
1941)